Dec
NBA Notebook #1 - Magic Johnson Edition
![]() |
Alright. We have our first NBA discussion, thanks to loyal RFS reader and RFS Chief Basketball Commentator Dan “Chitwood” McGillicuddy. Believe me, if you saw him back in the day… you’d know where the name came from. Many a team got caught watching the paint dry while Dan dropped 35 and 10 (assists) on them.
***Random RFS Trivia*** - The actor that played Jimmy Chitwood in the movie Hoosiers was the only actor in the movie (that portrayed a Hickory High player) that did NOT play college basketball.
——————————————————————–
In his submission, Dan writes:
“I would like to throw this out as the “greatest” starting five of all-time (that would actually function as a team is one of the key components):
PG - Earvin “Magic” Johnson
SG - Michael Jordan
SF - Larry Bird
PF - Tim Duncan
C - Bill Russell
I think you have two of the greatest passers (Magic and Bird), the greatest clutch shooters in Bird and MJ, the one-on-one ability of MJ and Duncan, and then the rebounding/blocks/hustle/winning plays of Russell.”
-RFS Chief Basketball Commentator Dan “Chitwood” McGillicuddy
———————————————————————————
We’ll get to the argument in a second, but in the interim, enjoy the following video of Magic.
Make sure to notice the following:
-The badass threaded pass to “Big Game” James Worthy (at 1:00)
-”Around the World” (at 1:05)
-The Magic to Michael Cooper “Coop-A-Loop” (at 1:09)
-SICK wraparound (at 1:25)
-Cheesy 80s-style celebration by AC Green and Magic (at 1:47)
The main thing to note is that Magic was doing these things when it was UNTHINKABLE that a 6′8″ guard could/would/should do them. Maybe Steve Nash (or his progenitor John Stockton) have some better highlights, but the thing about Magic is that he broke the ground. I don’t watch much NBA basketball - maybe 20-30 games per year - but I still don’t see threaded passes through traffic like Magic pulled off.
Anyway, my official RFS comment is that there are 2 spots up for debate on Dan’s list (5 years ago there would have been 3).
Five years ago many people would have argued for Karl Malone at PF, but since I hate that whiny foam-front, mesh-back, spandex-wearin’, free-throw-line-mumblin, sonuva… I’ll leave it at that. Tim Duncan is the right choice - for you hoops connisseurs out there, I think you’ll agree that NOBODY has ever used the glass better than Duncan. And I’ll fully admit - since “Chitwood” and I have known each other for many years - that I didn’t expect Duncan to be one of the great ones. Dan saw him at Wake and saw a Hall-of-Famer.
On to the All-Time Team argument:
The two possibly glaring omissions are… Oscar Robertson and Wilt Chamberlain. The Big O and Wilt the Stilt didn’t win many championships, but they changed the game.
Everybody knows that Oscar was the first guy to average a triple-double. Everybody knows that Wilt was the first to average 50 points per game.
But who do you kick off?
MJ is a lock. Magic is a lock. Bird is… a lock (we’ll cover the “if he was black, he’d be just another good player” topic at another time).
That leaves me with Duncan and Russell, both of whom I respect.
Very tough.
So tough that I can only bump one. Here’s my squad:
PG- Magic Johnson
SG - Michael Jordan
SF - Larry Bird
PF - Bill Russell
C - Wilt Chamberlain
![]() |
A very tough decision, but Wilt changed the game. Head to head, he DESTROYED Russell, and count me in the camp of people that believe a supporting cast IS important.
Wilt never had anybody around him. Big Russ had Hall-Of-Famers.
Furthermore, I think that Russell - while he couldn’t shoot a lick outside - would be an ideal power forward on a team-oriented squad.
And that’s just one man’s opinion. Thanks to Chitwood McGillicuddy for the submission.
And as one final treat, enjoy the video from the guy that just might be my favorite NBA player of all time. At the very least, he’s the captain of my all-time NBA Warrior Team (which we’ll cover at another time).
Even if you don’t watch the entire video, make sure you catch the dunk 37 seconds into the clip. Probably my vote for my favorite dunk ever (yet another topic), but at the very least you gotta love him rearing back and cranking on Bill “Tuuuurrrrrrrrrriiible” Walton. And keep in mind that the Round Mound was only 6′5″.
As always, comments and emails are welcome.
Peace and Chicken Grease,
RFS
Popularity: 32% [?]






